The New York Yankees announced on May 5 that José Caballero will remain the team’s everyday shortstop while Anthony Volpe has been optioned to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. The decision follows a recent stretch in which Caballero performed well both offensively and defensively.
This move is significant for the Yankees as it signals their commitment to maintaining a strong lineup with players who are currently performing at a high level. A National League scout said the team made a “great baseball decision,” noting that Caballero’s recent performance contributed to the choice.
Caballero has gone 19-for-57 with three home runs and four RBIs over his last 16 games. Defensively, he holds +3 outs above average, making him an asset in the field. In contrast, Volpe struggled during the previous season, posting a .212 batting average and -6 outs above average defensively. The scout said Volpe needs more time in the minor leagues before returning to Major League play: “[Volpe] struggled mightily last year. He wasn’t an asset to the Yankees… Right now, the Yankees feel Caballero is a better option at shortstop, probably both offensively and defensively. But we’ll see how [Volpe] performs. … The Yankees are trying to win.” The scout also suggested that if Volpe improves his performance in Triple-A, he could become valuable either for future play or as part of a trade deal.
Caballero commented on his new role as everyday shortstop: “It does help a lot [to play one position]. I have to practice there. You have to concentrate on getting better in that position.” He added about earning his spot: “I’m not the guy to make that decision. My goal is to help my team as much as I can to win and do my best every day… I try to help my team, for sure.” When asked about playing multiple positions earlier in his career—including pitching once for Tampa Bay—Caballero explained how focusing on one spot allows him greater consistency.
As observers watch how these changes affect both players’ futures with the organization, some believe Volpe may attract interest from other teams if he performs well in Triple-A. For now, Caballero remains focused on contributing at shortstop: “You really have to have your head clear,” he said.
